Senior football analyst from Malang, Gusnul Yakin, observes a significant tactical evolution in the Indonesian National Team under John Herdman, marking a departure from the static, possession-focused approach of the Shin Tae-yong era.
From Monotony to Dynamic Play
Yakin criticizes the previous tactical framework, noting that the Shin Tae-yong period was characterized by a rigid, defensive mindset that stifled creative expression. "The era of Shin Tae-yong gave us a monotonous game," he stated, attributing the lack of excitement to an excessive focus on defensive stability over offensive fluidity.
He drew parallels to Patrick Kluivert's tenure, where the team's obsession with ball possession led to a boring spectacle. "We were always worried about conceding goals," Yakin explained, highlighting the defensive caution that defined that period. - afhow
John Herdman's Tactical Balance
Contrastingly, Yakin praises John Herdman for successfully balancing all lines of play, fostering a more cohesive and responsive unit. The analyst highlighted specific tactical shifts that demonstrate this improved synergy:
- Simultaneous Support: Players now assist each other in real-time, creating a fluid defensive and attacking web.
- Positional Flexibility: Calvin Verdonk's move to midfield and Ole Romeny's drop from striker positions indicate a willingness to adapt roles dynamically.
- Defensive Depth: Jay Idzes and Rizki Ridho have advanced into the opponent's defensive zone, yet teammates remain ready to fill vacated positions.
Optimism for Future Success
Yakin remains confident that Herdman can finalize the construction of the Indonesian National Team, which was left unfinished by Shin Tae-yong and Patrick Kluivert. The analyst believes the new management has laid the groundwork for a more complete and competitive squad.
Source: Bola.com (Gatot Sumitro, Rizki Hidayat), March 31, 2026
